This cookies and cream “ice cream” is made with frozen bananas, whey protein, and coconut cream. it’s
packed with protein and cookies! Easy to make, so tasty, and the perfect treat that’s healthy and full of protein. Very little prep time needed to put this together.

Table of Contents

We all love having some ice cream every now and then. There is nothing better than homemade ice cream with some added protein. Made with simple and healthy ingredients like bananas, protein, and coconut cream. Cookies are optional but add a nice crunch and texture to the ice cream. If you can find sugar-free Oreos go for it! Enjoy these healthy cookies and cream protein ice cream without any guilt. So good!

Why this homemade protein ice cream is so good!

So easy to make: You only need a handful of ingredients to make this with only about 10 minutes of your time.
They are healthy: Yes. If you have sugar-free Oreos this protein icecream is super healthy and food for you!
So good: So tasty. The combination of bananas and coconut cream is so delicious. A must-try.

Ingredients you will need

Protein: any brand will do. Use your favorite flavor too.
Banana: use ripe bananas if you have them. Will add sweetness and more flavor.
Sweetener: we used maple syrup. Honey also works.
Cookies: use oreo thins or sugar-free kinds
Coconut cream: adds a thick and creamy texture and flavor.

How to make this protein ice cream

Place the bananas, coconut cream, maple syrup, and protein powder in a food processor.
Blend for 5-7 minutes or until the mixture is creamy and smooth.
Stir in the cookies. Place the “ice cream” in a container and freeze until ready to use.
Garnish with additional crushed cookies if desired.

FAQs and tips

Protein: Feel free to use your favorite protein brand and flavor.
Sweetener: Honey, maple syrup, or keto-approved syrups
We recommend using coconut cream for a thick creamy ice cream consistency. But you may substitute with milk like whole milk, rice milk, almond or cashew milk.
Cookies: Use Orea thins or sugar-free versions.

Can you put protein powder in ice cream

It is safe to add protein to your homemade ice cream. Protein powder will give you some added nutrition and protein to your homemade ice cream. Get a good dose of protein while indulging in a treat! Adding protein to store-bought ice cream full of fat and sugar does not make it a healthier option!

Does ice cream have a lot of protein

There are some ice cream brands that offer protein ice creams now. Even though they may be high in protein, do watch the labels for hidden sugars and fats. You may be able to find some great options out there but always best to make your own at home!

Can I use milk instead of cream

We used coconut cream to make this homemade protein ice cream. There are other options if you don’t have coconut cream. A not to ideal substitute would be to use heavy cream. You may also use milk which won’t give you that rich and creamy flavor but will still work. Any milk will work great like whole milk, almond milk, cashew milk, or rice milk.

Other recipes to check out

Remember to subscribe to my NEWSLETTER for free and receive recipes like this Homemade protein ice cream Recipe delivered right to your inbox!

If you try a recipe and you like it, please use our hashtag #healthyfitnessmeals on INSTAGRAM for a chance to be featured! FOLLOW Healthy Fitness Meals on FACEBOOK | INSTAGRAM | PINTEREST | TWITTER for all of our latest blog posts and recipes.